Work Study: Method Study & Time Study
Finding the best way to do a job and how long it should take. Learn method study (select, record, examine, develop, install, maintain), process charts and symbols, flow diagrams, motion economy and therbligs, time study with a stopwatch (cycles, rating, normal time, allowances, standard time), required sample size, predetermined motion time systems (MTM, MOST), work sampling, and standards for planning and incentives — with Python for a full time study.
Work study has two parts. Method study asks 'what is the best way to do this?' — removing unnecessary steps, motions and transport. Work measurement asks 'how long should it take a qualified worker at a normal pace?' — producing time standards for planning, costing, line balancing and fair incentives.
Good standards are the foundation of almost every other IE calculation: capacity, staffing, scheduling and cost all depend on them.
An analogy
Method study is like planning the fastest route before a road trip; time study is timing that route with a stopwatch, adjusting for how fast the driver actually drove and adding sensible stops for fuel and rest.
Method study
Steps (SREDIM): Select the job, Record the current method, Examine critically (what, where, when, who, how — and why?), Develop a better method, Install it, Maintain it. ASME process-chart symbols: operation (○), inspection (□), transport (→), delay (D), storage (▽). Flow diagrams and spaghetti charts reveal wasted walking and transport.
Principles of motion economy
From the Gilbreths' work:
- Use both hands simultaneously and symmetrically
- Keep materials and tools within the normal working area, in fixed locations
- Use gravity-feed bins and drop deliveries
- Use jigs and fixtures to free the hands
- Minimise eye movements and searching; good lighting and posture
- Eliminate therbligs like 'search', 'select', 'hold' where possible
Time study
Break the job into elements, time several cycles with a stopwatch (or video), rate the operator's pace against a defined normal, compute normal time, and add allowances (personal needs ~5%, basic fatigue ~4%, variable fatigue and delays) to obtain the standard time. Discard abnormal readings and foreign elements; use statistics to decide how many cycles are needed.
Predetermined times, work sampling and use of standards
Predetermined motion time systems (MTM-1, MTM-UAS, MOST) build times from tables of basic motions (reach, grasp, move, position) measured in TMUs (1 TMU = 0.036 s) — useful before a job exists. Work sampling uses random observations to estimate the fraction of time in each activity (e.g. machine idle %). Standards feed capacity planning, line balancing, costing and incentive schemes; they must be updated when methods change and applied ethically with worker involvement.
Formulas
- Normal time:
NT = OT × rating - Standard time (allowance on time):
ST = NT × (1 + A) - Standard time (allowance on workday):
ST = NT / (1 − A) - Sample size:
n = (z·s / (e·x̄))² - Work sampling sample size:
n = z²·p(1 − p)/h² - Standard output:
units/hour = 60 / ST
Worked example: Standard time
Given: OT 0.514 min, rating 110%, allowance 15%
Find: ST.
- NT = 0.565
- ST = 0.565 × 1.15
Answer: 0.650 min
Worked example: Allowance on workday
Given: NT 2.0 min, allowance 12% of the workday
Find: ST.
- 2.0/(1 − 0.12)
Answer: 2.27 min
Worked example: Work sampling
Given: Estimate machine idle % ≈ 20%, ±3% absolute, 95% confidence
Find: Observations.
- n = 1.96² × 0.2 × 0.8/0.03²
Answer: 683 random observations
Stopwatch time study
import math, statistics
# Stopwatch time study: normal time, standard time and required number of cycles
obs = [0.52, 0.49, 0.55, 0.50, 0.53, 0.48, 0.51, 0.54, 0.50, 0.52] # minutes
rating = 1.10 # operator works 10% faster than normal
allowance = 0.15 # personal, fatigue & delay allowance
mean = statistics.mean(obs)
normal = mean * rating
standard = normal * (1 + allowance)
print(f"observed {mean:.3f} min, normal {normal:.3f} min, standard {standard:.3f} min")
print(f"standard output: {60/standard:.1f} units/hour, {480/standard:.0f} per 8-h shift")
# Cycles needed for +/-5% accuracy at 95% confidence
s = statistics.stdev(obs)
n = (1.96 * s / (0.05 * mean)) ** 2
print(f"s = {s:.4f} min -> required observations n = {math.ceil(n)}")
# observed 0.514 min, normal 0.565 min, standard 0.650 min
# standard output: 92.3 units/hour, 738 per 8-h shift
# s = 0.0222 min -> required observations n = 3Because this operator was faster than normal, the rating raises the time; allowances then add personal, fatigue and delay time. This task is very consistent (small s), so few cycles are needed; variable tasks need many more. Always observe enough cycles and multiple operators.
Common mistakes
- Wrong: Timing before the method is improved. — Right: Do method study first, then time the good method.
- Wrong: Studying a learner or unusually fast worker without rating. — Right: Rate pace against a defined normal.
- Wrong: Too few cycles for variable tasks. — Right: Compute the required sample size.
Applications
- Assembly lines: Standards for line balancing and staffing.
- Costing: Labour cost per unit for quotations.
- Warehouses: Engineered labour standards for picking.
- Healthcare: Nurse workload and staffing models.
Key takeaways
- Method study first (SREDIM), then time study.
- ST = OT × rating × (1 + allowance).
- Use statistics for sample size.
- Standards drive staffing, balancing and cost.
Going further
- MOST: Maynard Operation Sequence Technique for faster standard setting.
- Video & AI time study: Computer vision extracting cycle elements.
- Learning-curve models: Wright's law for new product ramp-up.